Tuesday, July 6, 2021

Oh Snap! Am I a Flipper?

The San Francisco Giants have dominated local sports radio for weeks... but on my way to the post office this morning, they weren't talking about Buster Posey, Kevin Gausman, or Brandon Crawford.  They were talking about Shohei Ohtani.  And rightfully so, because he's making history and bringing positive attention to baseball.  And based on a sale I made this morning... his cards (at least some of them) are on fire.

About a month ago, I listed three of the four graded Ohtani rookie cards I purchased last summer.  Now this was a big decision for me, because up until now I have only sold two types of cards on eBay.

#1Cards I have multiple copies of.

#2Cards that aren't part of personal collections.

None of these three cards are duplicates and obviously Ohtani is part of my Japanese PC.  So... why would I cross the line and decide to sell these cards?

It's simple.  He's been hot and opportunities like this don't happen very often.

Here's a look at the card I sold this morning:

2018 Topps Chrome Sepia Refractor #150

And here's how much I paid for it:


Just over a year ago, I went out and purchased this card on COMC for $54.10.  This was a few weeks before the start of the delayed season and I wanted to add a few of his rookie cards to my collection.  At the time, I seriously debated spending this much money on graded rookie cards of a twenty-five year old player with a history of injuries.  Obviously, I pulled the trigger.

Last week, I sold this Ohtani for $155:

2018 Bowman's Best #1

Here's my purchase price:


Now if these cards were only selling for double or triple my purchase price, I would have held onto them.  However like I stated earlier... opportunities like this don't happen too often.

It's hard to determine what I'll actually end up putting into my pocket after factoring in eBay fees, income taxes, and additional shipping costs.  Whatever the profit is... it's only a small fraction of the money I've pour into the hobby over the years.

Plus... I don't want to give off the impression that it's all rainbows and butterflies.  For every Ohtani graded rookie card purchase, I've made purchases like these:



It's also a little sad to see my Ohtani collection shrink by two cards:


The last remaining Ohtani that I have up for sale is this card:

2018 Stadium Club #138

I really like this card, so I'm not in any rush to sell this card.  However... like the other two cards... if someone is willing to open up their wallet, I won't pass up an opportunity.

The one graded Ohtani I decided to keep is this rookie card:

2018 Topps #700

When I started listing these Ohtani cards, I knew I wanted to keep one.  I went with this one, because it features a nice action shot.

Plus if Ohtani rookie cards continue to soar in value, I want to make sure I have a least one graded card of his in my collection.  And if he does come back down to earth, then I'll be ready to step in and repurchase these cards for discounted prices... just like I did with guys like Hideo Nomo, Daisuke Matsuzaka, and Kenji Johjima.

Speaking of these three guys, Dennis over at Too Many Verlanders recently sent me a care package that contained all three of these players, plus a few other Japanese baseball players:

2008 Upper Deck UD Game Jersey #UDJ-KJ
2004 UD Sweet Spot Sweet Threads #STS-KM
2009 Upper Deck Goudey Memorabilia #GM-DM


Dennis also sent me these two Oakland A's hits:

2004 UD Sweet Spot Sweet Threads #STS-TH
2006 Bowman Signs of the Future #SOF-TB

Back in May or April, I received a huge care package from Xavier Higgins who reads and comments on my blog.  He recently sent another package, which I have combined and sorted with his first package:


He sent me quite the variety... which covered several different areas of my collection.  One of those areas was my Japanese PC.  Here's a sweet Ichiro manufactured relic he gave me:

2021 Topps 70th Anniversary Manufactured Logo Patch #70LP-I

He actually sent a few other manufactured patches as well as a bunch of memorabilia cards that will eventually get featured in a post.  But for now, I'll wrap things up with 9 more Japanese cards he sent my way:


Thank you Dennis and Xavier for contributing more cards to my collection of Japanese athletes!

Here is today's question of the day...

Who is the first Japanese baseball player that pops into your head?

Do you have a favorite Japanese baseball player?

Have you ever sold a card that was part of your personal collection?

It's hard to say which Japanese player would pop into my head first, because I just flipped through all of my binders this morning... but I'm guess it would be Hideo Nomo.  As for my favorites... I'd say Ichiro and Kurt Suzuki.

Well that's it for today.  I hope all of you have a great week.  Happy Tuesday and sayonara!


Extra Innings


By the way... I just spent $16.49 to have my COMC inventory shipped to me.  I thought about paying the regular flat rate price, but I didn't want to wait until November to receive my cards.

According to COMC, my estimated shipping date is next Friday:


We'll see how that goes.  

20 comments:

Bulldog said...

Great cards. It's hard not to take advantage of the spike in prices when you can. So many great cards in this post. Really liked Hudson from his time with the Braves. Ohtani is a fun guy to collect because of the great things he does. I need to dig out the cards of his I have. Many of which are probably sitting in a long box. Good post.

night owl said...

1. Nomo
2. Nomo
3. No

I sold a few Ohtani cards a month or so ago. I didn't get a whole lot, probably because they weren't graded. But I figure what I don't get because my cards aren't graded is what I didn't spend getting them graded.

Elliptical Man said...

I might have to complain about graded cards in a future post. Good job though.

Sadaharu Oh.

Not really. Ichiro and Ohtani would be the closest.

I don't sell my cards. But I traded my 1/1 Adrian Peterson swatch card.

Sean said...

Its amazing to watch Ohtani's season unfold, especially here in Japan where he is dominating the headlines probably even more than he is there!

Its hard for me to answer the first two of your questions since I follow NPB closer than MLB so most of the players I know are Japanese. Also I haven't really had a favorite player since Don Mattingly retired, but I do have some guys I like to collect (Sadaharu Oh, Ichiro, Isao Harimoto, Sachio Kinugasa and a few others).

I've only sold one card from my collection in the past 28 years, and that was just because someone else wanted it more than I did (a Japanese Brooks Robinson card I had which an Orioles fan was trying to track down) rather than to finance my collection, though I probably did end up spending the money on cards!

John Sharp said...

Sadahara Oh, Ichiro, and, Yes.

Johnnys Trading Spot said...

These days, Ohtani pops into mind. I wonder what I would pull in if I sold those two rookie pack pulled autos of his I have? Or the first Topps cards (NOW) I think I still have a few of those laying around.

Adam Kaningher said...

First one I thought of is Kenta Maeda. For a favorite I might say Hideki Matsui.

CinciCuse Bill said...

I’m with Elliptical and John - Sadaharu Oh, then Ichiro, but I’ve not parted with a pc since I was a kid.

Anonymous said...

Nothing wrong with selling 'high' at those prices. I'd thought that Ohtani cards were undervalued last year, but was too focused on vintage I guess. I'll have to wait until the market cools to pick up his Topps Chrome RC for my set.

Hideo Nomo is probably my all-time favorite Japanese player, even though Ichiro, Othani, and even Hideki Matsui come to mind first. I got swept up in Nomo-mania back in the day.

I've had mixed success selling PC players on the rare times I've done so. My biggest regret was selling my Robin Yount PSA 8 RC to try to fund a PSA 9. I still couldn't afford the 9 and now I don't have either one :/

NPB Card Guy said...

I'm with Sean in that the the first two questions are hard for me to answer due to the nature of my collection. As for the third question, I've occasionally been given an offer on something that overwhelmed me enough I sold the card.

I have to say I'm really impressed that the one Japanese card you have of Ohtani isn't one that I have. That's from the "Grateful Days" box set BBM put out after he signed with the Angels. I've never been able to find that set for a price I was willing to pay.

Matt said...

I still don't sell anything even with dupes, but I do use rising values like this and trade a player away so it's almost the same thing. I trade em while they are hot for something I want more.

SumoMenkoMan said...

Hideo Nomi and Ichiro pop into my head first! I’d like to think Ohtani rookies are going to come back down, but even his Japanese rookies are skyrocketing! I don’t blame you for putting a bit of money in your pocket.

GTT said...

1. Sadaharu Oh
2. Current: Shohei Ohtani Retired: Ichiro
3. Yes, but I have a loose definition of personal collection.

The Snorting Bull said...

1. So Taguchi
2. So Taguchi
3. Yes, several times. I swear I am never going to do it again, until I do. Always end up disappointed.

Steve at 1975BaseballCards.com said...

1. Ichiro
2. Ohtani partially because I feel like he's an underdog due to the hype and injuries so I'd like to see him overcome all that.
3. Like others, depends on what PC means. Mostly it's dupes and even then it's not a lot. The last year sure worked out for those who were liquidating their collections.

Nick said...

1. Ichiro
2. Ichiro
3. I don't sell cards very often, and the few I have sold recently were parallels of regular base cards I already own that netted me way too much money to pass up. Sold my 2018 Topps Chrome Update Juan Soto rookie, for instance, which is fine with me since I still have the regular Update base.

Anonymous said...

Len Sakata. Was he Japanese? Don't want to be canceled for mis-nationalizing.

gcrl said...

If you are letting the free market determine the price I would say you are a seller and not a flipper. If you were buying up retail stock and holding the product hostage at inflated buy it now prices, that would be different.

Fuji said...

bulldog - hudson was my favorite among the big three and i continued to root for him in atlanta (not as much in sf). bust out those ohtanis and show them off!

night owl - the whole graded thing is crazy. i've never sent anything in myself to get graded, but there are some vintage items i need to get slabbed for authentication purposes. but the cost per card continues to get out of hand

elliptical man - a lot of people aren't fans of graded cards. i've accepted that. at one time i wasn't either. things are starting to change though. i'm considering selling my graded cards if i have a raw copy in the collection. nice call on sadaharu oh. i wish he was the first japanese player that popped into my head, since he's a legend.

sean - i understand about the first two questions. a japanese brooks robinson card? that sounds really cool.

john sharp - wish sadaharu was the first japanese player to pop into my head. he's a legend for sure. ichiro too.

johnnys trading spot - i'm sure you're sitting on a lot of money with those ohtani autographs. probably could purchase you a few some nice braves autographs

adam kaningher - i like maeda. hope he bounces back after a subpar (for his standards) first half. i was so glad when godzilla came to play with the a's in the early 2010's. if he wasn't a yankee for so long, i'd like him more

cincicuse bill - love me some oh and ichiro. two of japan's finest for sure.

chris - nomo was part of the reason i embraced the japanese culture more. nomo-mania was so fun to watch... just like fernando before him and ohtani today. hope you get that psa 9 yount one day. the ohtani chrome too.

npb card guy - i imagine when your collection focuses on japanese players it's hard to pick a favorite or think of the first guy who pops into your head. thanks for the info on the grateful days card. it's the only japanese card i own of him and was a gift from a fellow blogger.

matt - i'm the exact opposite... in the sense that i don't really trade anymore. but if i did... i'd probably trade them while they were hot too.

sumomenkoman - you're sitting on a gold mine with those japanese rookie boxes. i sure hope he eventually comes down in price, so i can pick up more of his cards. but he hit another home run last night, so it's not going to happen anytime soon

gtt - oh, ohtani, and ichiro are awesome selections. what's your definition of personal collection?

the snorting bull - pretty sure you're the first to throw down taguchi's name. i remember him though.

steve at 1975baseballcards.com - i sure hope ohtani will be able to remain healthy from this point moving forward. and yeah... this past year was a great time to cash in on the hobby if you were thinking of leaving. i'm not, but even before the pandemic i had decided to collect differently.

nick - i love me some ichiro. the whole "too much money to pass up" plays a big role in selling on ebay. if i wanted to, i could double or triple my money on 80% of the graded rookie cards i've purchased over the years. but i'm not going to sell them unless they are going for "stupid" prices.

anonymous - yup he's japanese. last i heard... he was managing the san jose giants

gcrl - i like your definitions, because then i'm a seller. thanks for making me feel better jim ;D

Nick Vossbrink said...

1st: Sadaharu Oh
Favorite: Gonna go with Murakami though Ohtani is making a run for it (and I did like Ichiro too)
And I've never sold a card period. But I've also never even traded a PC card. I've also never had a card that was selling for stupid money either though.